Science10 min read
Is it harder to quit smoking or vaping? What the research says

For most people, quitting smoking is a little harder than quitting vaping, but the difference is smaller than you might expect. Large surveys find that people who only vape are, on average, less dependent on nicotine than people who only smoke. When daily vapers stop, though, they get the same withdrawal symptoms as smokers, and researchers who measured them found the symptoms were "only somewhat less" severe than those from cigarettes.
So the honest answer depends on how you use nicotine. A strong nicotine salt pod used all day can deliver as much nicotine, as fast, as a pack of cigarettes. A vape is also easy to use far more often and in more places, which gives you more habits to break. And people who both smoke and vape have the hardest time of all.
The short answer
Dependence: on average a bit lower in people who only vape than in people who only smoke
Withdrawal: the same symptoms, only somewhat milder after vaping
Harder for vapers when: you use strong salt pods, puff all day or switched from smoking
Hardest of all: using both cigarettes and a vape
How long it lasts: withdrawal peaks in the first week and most symptoms fade over 2 to 4 weeks
Is vaping more addictive than cigarettes?
Not on average. The best data comes from the US Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) study, which surveys thousands of adults about their tobacco use.
A 2017 analysis of PATH data compared 156 adults who only vaped with 3,430 who only smoked. The vapers waited longer after waking before their first use (about 29 minutes against 20), and smokers were far more likely to describe themselves as addicted. The authors concluded that daily vapers "are less dependent on their respective product than comparable cigarette smokers."
A larger 2020 study of 13,311 US adults across three waves of PATH reached the same verdict: e-cigarette use "appears to be consistently associated with lower nicotine dependence than cigarette smoking." It also found something worth knowing if you switched. The vapers with the highest dependence were the ones who had stopped smoking. If you moved from cigarettes to a vape, your vape habit is probably stronger than that of someone who never smoked.
Why cigarettes still have the edge
Cigarette smoke is more than nicotine. A study in Nature found that smokers' brains had 40% less of the enzyme monoamine oxidase B than the brains of non-smokers or former smokers. That enzyme breaks down dopamine, so smoke may keep more dopamine around than nicotine alone would. Smoking also comes with decades of ritual for many people: the break outside, the lighter, the cigarette with a drink. For the brain chemistry behind all this, see our guide to the science behind nicotine addiction.
Is vape withdrawal easier than cigarette withdrawal?
Only slightly. In a clinical trial, 109 former smokers who vaped every day used their own e-cigarette for a week and then tried to stop for six days, with their abstinence checked by tests. All the standard tobacco withdrawal symptoms rose when they stopped, along with cravings for both e-cigarettes and cigarettes. The researchers wrote that the severity of withdrawal from e-cigarettes "appears to be only somewhat less than that from daily tobacco cigarette use."
Only half of the group managed a full week without vaping, even with a research team checking on them. That is a fair warning that vaping is not an easy habit to drop. If you want to know what those first days without a vape feel like, our list of the side effects of quitting vaping goes through each symptom and how long it usually lasts.
The timeline is the same as for smoking. A review of 120 studies found that anger, anxiety, low mood, poor concentration, impatience, insomnia and restlessness "peak within the first week and last 2-4 weeks." Our nicotine withdrawal timeline goes through it hour by hour, and the mental fog is the same whichever product you give up, as we explain in nicotine withdrawal brain fog.
| Quitting cigarettes | Quitting a vape | |
|---|---|---|
| Average dependence | Higher | Somewhat lower, but highest in former smokers |
| Withdrawal symptoms | Cravings, irritability, anxiety, low mood, poor sleep, hunger | The same list, only somewhat milder |
| How long the worst lasts | Peaks in week one, fades over 2 to 4 weeks | Same pattern |
| Habit cues | Fixed moments: breaks, coffee, drinks, after meals | Spread through the whole day, often indoors |
| Tested treatments | Decades of trials of patches, gum, varenicline and counselling | A handful of trials so far, mostly in young people |
Cigarettes or vape, the first month is the same
QuitNic tracks your nicotine-free days, shows what your body is doing at each stage and gives you 24/7 AI coaching when a craving hits.
Download QuitNicWhen quitting vaping is harder than quitting smoking
The averages hide a lot of people for whom vaping is the tougher habit. You are more likely to be one of them in these situations.
You use strong nicotine salt pods
Pod devices with nicotine salts deliver nicotine much like a cigarette. In a lab study by Hajek and colleagues, a US Juul raised blood nicotine to a peak of 20.4 ng/ml in 4 minutes, against 19.2 ng/ml in 6 minutes for a cigarette. It also gave a faster, higher peak than the other e-cigarettes tested, despite fewer puffs.
The amount adds up quickly too. A review of eight studies concluded that one JUULpod "appears capable of delivering the nicotine equivalent to smoking about a pack of cigarettes." If you get through a pod or a disposable a day, assume your dependence is at least that of a pack-a-day smoker.
Strength limits matter here. In the UK and EU, e-liquids are capped at 20 mg/ml, and a follow-up study found the EU Juul produced a peak of 3.8 ng/ml against 21.1 ng/ml for the 59 mg/ml US version. Illegal high-strength disposables do not follow that cap, so check what you are actually using.
You vape all day
A cigarette ends after a few minutes and you usually have to go outside to smoke one. A vape has no end and works almost anywhere: at your desk, in the car, in bed. It is easy to take a puff every few minutes without noticing. Each of those puffs links nicotine to another place, time or feeling, so when you quit there are more cues to unlearn and fewer stretches of the day that already feel nicotine-free.
That is why quitting vaping often feels harder even when the measured dependence is lower. It can also explain other symptoms: very high daily doses can upset the stomach, which we cover in can vaping cause diarrhea.
You switched from smoking
The 2020 PATH study found the highest e-cigarette dependence among vapers who used to smoke. Your brain spent years adapting to cigarettes, and the vape picked up where they left off. You may also still crave cigarettes when you stop vaping: in the withdrawal trial above, cigarette cravings rose alongside vape cravings.
You smoke and vape
This is the hardest position to quit from. A 2025 systematic review in ERJ Open Research of 16 studies found that "relatively fewer" people who used both products stopped all nicotine than people who only smoked or only vaped. Each product covers the gaps the other leaves: a vape where you cannot smoke, a cigarette when the vape is not enough.
When quitting smoking is harder
Cigarettes tend to be the harder habit if you have smoked for many years, smoke within minutes of waking, or have built smoking into fixed parts of your day such as breaks at work, coffee and drinking. Long-standing rituals take longer to replace than a habit you picked up recently. Smokers also get the strongest cigarette cravings in the situations where they always smoked, which makes those moments the ones to plan for. Our guide to the best time to quit smoking covers how to pick a quit date that keeps the first hard days away from your biggest triggers.
On the other hand, smokers have far more tested help. Nicotine patches, gum and lozenges, varenicline and stop-smoking services have been studied in smokers for decades. That help works whichever product you use, but the evidence for vapers is much thinner, as the next section shows.
What helps you quit each one
Quitting cigarettes
- Use proper treatment. That means nicotine replacement, often a patch plus gum or lozenges for the bad moments, or varenicline from your doctor. Our comparison of lozenges, patches and gum explains the options.
- Plan your fixed triggers. Write down when you always smoke and decide in advance what you will do at each one.
- Do not swap to vaping and stay there. If you use a vape to stop smoking, stop smoking completely and plan when you will stop vaping, so you do not end up as a dual user.
Quitting a vape
The evidence is newer and more limited. A 2025 Cochrane review found nine randomised trials with 5,209 participants. Its main findings:
- Varenicline doubled vaping quit rates at six months in one trial of 140 people, though the evidence is rated low certainty. Ask your doctor about it if you have tried before and gone back.
- Text message programmes may help 13 to 24 year olds stop. In a trial of 2,588 young adults, 24.1% of those who got the texts had stopped vaping at seven months, against 18.6% of those who did not.
- Nicotine replacement and cutting down nicotine strength have not been tested well enough in vapers to say whether they work.
Beyond that, the practical steps are about breaking the constant-puffing habit:
- Count your use for a few days before you quit, so you know how often you reach for it and when.
- Make it harder to reach. Leave the vape in a bag or another room instead of your pocket.
- Step down in strength if a sudden stop feels impossible, but set a final date.
- Have something for your hands and mouth, such as gum, a water bottle or a toothpick, for the moments the device used to fill.
Our guide to quitting vaping has a full step-down plan. Logging every session by hand gets old quickly, which is where a phone app helps. Most quit apps were built for cigarettes, so check that yours can track a vape too; our comparison of the best quit smoking apps notes which ones do, and our ranking of the best quit vaping apps looks only at options for people who vape.
Which should you quit first if you use both?
If you can, stop both on the same day. The withdrawal is the same nicotine withdrawal either way, so you only go through it once. If that feels like too much, stop smoking first, because cigarettes do far more harm, and then use a fixed plan to step down and stop vaping within a few weeks. Our article on whether vaping is safer than smoking sets out the difference in harm.
What does not work well is drifting between the two with no end date. That is the pattern the 2025 review linked to the lowest quit rates.
When to get extra help
Talk to your doctor or a local stop-smoking service if you use nicotine within minutes of waking, get through a pod or disposable a day, have tried to quit several times, or have depression or anxiety that gets worse when you stop. They can prescribe varenicline, set you up with nicotine replacement and keep an eye on your mood while you quit.
The bottom line
Is it harder to quit smoking or vaping? For the average person, smoking is slightly harder: smokers are more dependent, and vape withdrawal is a little milder. But the gap is small, and it closes or flips if you use strong salt pods all day or switched from smoking to vaping. Using both is the hardest of all.
Either way, the symptoms are the same, they peak in the first week and most of them are gone within a month. For ways to get through the cravings in that time, see our strategies to overcome nicotine cravings.
Ready to quit for good?
QuitNic tracks your nicotine-free days, shows your health milestones and gives you 24/7 AI coaching when a craving hits.
Download QuitNicFrequently Asked Questions
Is it harder to quit smoking or vaping?
For the average person, quitting smoking is slightly harder. Large US surveys find that people who only vape are less dependent than people who only smoke, and a clinical trial found that withdrawal from e-cigarettes is only somewhat milder than withdrawal from cigarettes. The gap is small, though, and it shrinks or reverses for people who use strong nicotine salt pods all day, people who switched from smoking to vaping, and people who do both.
Is vaping more addictive than cigarettes?
Not on average. In the US PATH study, people who only vaped waited longer before their first use of the day and were far less likely to call themselves addicted than people who only smoked. A strong pod can still deliver nicotine about as fast and as high as a cigarette, and one JUULpod can hold about a pack's worth, so a heavy pod user can be as hooked as a heavy smoker.
Is vape withdrawal worse than cigarette withdrawal?
Usually not, but it is close. In a trial of 109 former smokers who vaped daily, every standard nicotine withdrawal symptom went up when they stopped vaping, and the authors concluded the severity was only somewhat less than withdrawal from daily smoking. Expect the same pattern: a peak in the first week and most symptoms fading over two to four weeks.
Why does quitting vaping feel harder than quitting smoking?
Mostly because of how often you use it. A vape has no natural end, works indoors and sits in your pocket, so it is easy to take a puff every few minutes without thinking. That links nicotine to almost every moment of the day, which means more cues to break. The nicotine dependence itself is, on average, a little lower than with cigarettes.
Is it harder to quit if I smoke and vape?
Yes. A 2025 systematic review in ERJ Open Research found that people who both smoke and vape were less likely to stop all nicotine than people who only smoked or only vaped. If you use both, pick one quit date for both, or stop smoking completely first and then follow a plan to stop vaping.
Sources
- 1
Liu G, Wasserman E, Kong L, Foulds J. A comparison of nicotine dependence among exclusive E-cigarette and cigarette users in the PATH study. Preventive Medicine, 2017.
- 2
Shiffman S, Sembower MA. Dependence on e-cigarettes and cigarettes in a cross-sectional study of US adults. Addiction, 2020.
- 3
Fowler JS, et al. Inhibition of monoamine oxidase B in the brains of smokers. Nature, 1996.
- 4
Hughes JR, Peters EN, et al. Withdrawal Symptoms From E-Cigarette Abstinence Among Former Smokers: A Pre-Post Clinical Trial. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 2020.
- 5
Hughes JR. Effects of abstinence from tobacco: valid symptoms and time course. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 2007.
- 6
Hajek P, et al. Nicotine delivery and users' reactions to Juul compared with cigarettes and other e-cigarette products. Addiction, 2020.
- 7
Prochaska JJ, Vogel EA, Benowitz N. Nicotine delivery and cigarette equivalents from vaping a JUULpod. Tobacco Control, 2022.
- 8
Phillips-Waller A, et al. Nicotine delivery and user reactions to Juul EU (20 mg/ml) compared with Juul US (59 mg/ml), cigarettes and other e-cigarette products. Psychopharmacology, 2021.
- 9
Hamoud J, et al. A systematic review investigating the impact of dual use of e-cigarettes and conventional cigarettes on smoking cessation. ERJ Open Research, 2025.
- 10
Butler AR, et al. Interventions for quitting vaping. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2025.
- 11
Graham AL, et al. Effectiveness of a Vaping Cessation Text Message Program Among Young Adult e-Cigarette Users: A Randomized Clinical Trial. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2021.